History from Here: Former Zion Baptist Church

One of the earliest parishes to serve Freedom Seekers settling in St. Catharines in the mid-nineteenth century, the legacy of the Zion Baptist Church reflects the resilience of the community, that together, built new lives here and thrived as free people.

On this episode of History From Here, Sara takes you to the former location of the Zion Baptist Church on Geneva Street in St. Catharines, Ontario.


Freedom Seekers, or black refugees escaping slavery from the southern United States, sought refuge in Niagara as early as the 1820s and 1830s. To meet the needs of the growing black community here, missionary Reverend Elder Washington Christian established the first Baptist parish in St. Catharines in 1838. Over the course of a few short years, the congregation, consisting of almost all Freedom Seekers, raised enough funds to purchase a plot of land from local abolitionist and businessman, William Hamilton Merritt. With his financial assistance, the congregants built the Zion Baptist Church using their own tools and carpentry skills. It was constructed of a wood frame in a modest architectural design typical of other early churches built by Black community members in Canada at the time. The interior consisted of three sections of pews with Bible verses painted on the walls. The chapel officially opened in 1844.

The former Zion Baptist Church, in 1955. At this time, the congregation had already moved to a different location and the building was not in use. It was torn down in 1958. STCM S1955.14.6.1

Though on the outskirts of bustling St. Catharines, the area around Zion, by what we’re now familiar with as Geneva and North Streets, quickly grew to serve the needs of the flourishing black community. Known as Coloured Town, this neighbourhood was where, for the first time, Freedom Seekers could thrive as free people. Here, community members could purchase land and build their own homes, tend their own gardens, earn living wages, operate their own businesses, and form the social connections and activities integral to a vibrant community. The Zion Baptist Church was a major hub for such social activity in Coloured Town, organizing plays, pageants, picnics and providing resources and support for newly arriving Freedom Seekers.

In fact, one of the Church’s most well-known pastors was himself a Freedom Seeker. Born a slave in 1834 Virginia, Anthony Burns made his escape the age of 19, finding freedom and employment in Boston. However, his time as a free man was cut short when only a few months later, in May 1854, he was re-captured and tried under the Fugitive Slave Act. The decision that Burns would be returned to his owner in Virginia ignited the Boston Slave Riot of 1854, where thousands gathered in a protest against slavery. Eventually, Boston abolitionists would raise enough money to purchase Burns’ freedom and offer him a scholarship to pursue education in Ohio. After becoming ordained, Burns came to St. Catharines in 1860 where he became pastor at the Zion Baptist Church. Sadly, he died only two years later from tuberculosis. Reverend Anthony Burns is buried in Victoria Lawn Cemetery, where a plaque stands in his honour.

A sketch depicting the life of Anthony Burns. STCM 9843-N.

Despite facing numerous financial and leadership challenges throughout much of its history, the Zion Baptist Church, imbued with the resilience of its community, continued to serve as a place of welcome and worship until 1927, when the chapel closed its doors. The parish would eventually relocate a home on Raymond Street, which was bequeathed to congregation by one of its members.

The “Coloured Town” neighbourhood was located in the area around Geneva St., North St., and Welland Avenue, as shown here on the 1913 St. Catharines Fire Insurance Plan. The Zion Baptist Church building was marked as “Coloured Church” on the map. Few tangible remnants of this historic neighbourhood of Freedom Seekers remain. STCM 1972.31.1.4B

The original Zion Baptist Church building was demolished in 1958. As with the fate of the chapel, little tangible evidence remains of the mid-nineteenth century Coloured Town neighbourhood, of course with a few exceptions, including the Salem Chapel. Instead, the descendants and the legacy of St. Catharines’ early Black community has woven itself through the fabric of the City and into our collective identity.


  1. How did the Colored community disappear? My imminent domain?, intent to make it disappear or movement of residents

    • Hi Victoria. The community evolved over time. After the Civil War ended and the Emancipation Proclamation took effect, many refugees returned to the United States to reunite with family. Some did stay and settle, but as with all urban development, properties come and go, and neighbourhoods experience change. Many descendants of refugees still live in St. Catharines and throughout Niagara today.

  2. Was that the Geneva House across the street on the map (corner of Geneva and Welland). If so was it connect to the Black community on North Street?

    • Hi Marty,
      Yes – Geneva House was at the corner of Geneva and Welland. We haven’t found a specific reference or connection to the Black community there but if we do, we’ll share it here.
      Great question!

Leave a Reply